The top 6 questions

1. Who can bring a claim?
You can join the action if you purchased or owned an affected vehicle, whether it was purchased new or second hand. You can also participate if you have already sold the affected vehicle, provided that you have proof of your previous ownership (including the vehicle’s VIN number). You can also instruct us to claim if you bought the car outright with cash, or financed it through Volkswagen Financial Services or through any other form of financing.

2. What will it cost me?
The litigation will be funded by a third party litigation funder. Accordingly, there will be no cost to you for joining or participating in the group action. If we lose the claim, the funder will lose all of its investment. To offset its risk, the litigation funder will take a fee from the compensation awarded if we are successful. You should however still receive 70% of your proportionate share of compensation. If we lose the claim, we will not charge you for our time or the costs we have incurred on your behalf.  The funder will simply lose its investment.

3. What are my risks?
Any claimants involved in a Court case could be ordered to pay the defendants’ legal costs if they lose. This is a characteristic of the Court system in England and Wales. In order to protect claimants from that risk, we have obtained an indemnity from the Third Party Funder who are responsible for obtaining insurance.  If the case is lost, it will be the Third Party Funder or their insurers who will pay the other side’s costs up to the level of the amount insured. It is our duty to minimise the risk to you as far as possible, and the funder’s indemnity and Insurance should mean that the risk will be negligible. Other risks are referred to in the Claim Summary document, which we have prepared and which is available to prospective claimants during the registration process.

4. Do I need to have the ‘fix’ carried out?
No. There is no legal obligation for you to have the ‘fix’ if you do not want to. VW have said the affected vehicles remain roadworthy in their current state and that they will not fail their MOT because of the NOx issue. As we do not know precisely how the fix works, we cannot definitively say whether owners of affected vehicles ought to have their cars fixed or not. At this stage we do not think that having your car fixed will compromise your claim.  The reason behind this is that, regardless of the effect of the fix, you will still (we believe) have overpaid for vehicle at the point of purchase and should be compensated accordingly.

5. Can I still be a part of the Group Action if I do / do not have the ‘fix’?
You can be part of the Group Action against VW regardless of whether you have had or not had your affected vehicle ‘fixed’. You will still have overpaid for your vehicle at the point of purchase and have been should be compensated accordingly.

6. I bought my car in Scotland / Northern Ireland. Can I join the Group Action?
Unfortunately we are unable to act for those people who purchased their cars in Scotland or Northern Ireland. We are investigating how we might help though, and will keep you updated on our progress if you register your interest here. If you purchased your car in England or Wales and now live in Scotland or Northern Ireland then you can join the action, if you can provide proof of where you purchased the car.

Background to the claim                                                                                                                                   
1. What is the VW emissions scandal?
2. What is the claim about?3. What is VW doing about this?4. What is the UK government doing about this?

What are the allegations against VW?
5. What legal action (claim) is the VW emissions Action Group going to make? 
6. What is it alleged that VW did wrong? 
7. What are the rules that govern the sale of motor vehicles?

Joining the group?
8. Why should I claim?
9. What are you asking me to do?
10. What is the VW Emissions Action Group?
11. What will it cost me?
12. How can I be part of the claim?
13. What do I need to do in order to join the claim?
14. What if I want to make a different claim?
15. Who can bring a claim?
16. How do I know if my car is affected?
17. I bought my car in Scotland / Northern Ireland. Can I join the Group Action?
18. Can I still bring a claim if I have sold my affected vehicle?

How it works
19. In which Court has the case been brought?
20. What is a Group Litigation Order? 
21. What is a Group Action?

22. What documents / information do I need to keep or have to be part of the claim?
23. What barristers are the VW emission action group using?
24. Will I have to go to Court if I appoint the VW actions group to represent me?
25. Who are the defendants?

Financial matters26. How much compensation will I get?
27. What is the loss that is being claimed for? 
28. Can we seek to punish VW for its alleged conduct?
29. How much of the compensation I am awarded will I get to keep?

30. What is Third Party Funding? 
31. Will I get a new car if you win the litigation?
32. How do Harcus Sinclair, Slater and Gordon and the Third Party Funder get paid?
33. Do I still need to be making my monthly payments to VW Financial Services if I am suing VW?

Environmental issues
34. What is NOx?
35. What effect does NOx have on the environment? 
36. What effect does NOx have on our health? 

What being in the claim will mean for me 
37. Can I speak to a lawyer about the progress of the claim?
38. How long will the litigation take?
39. How will I know what the outcome is and what happens next? 
40. What are my risks?
41. How can I sign up for updates? 
42. What if I have already signed up with another group?
43. What happens if I want to leave the Group Action once it has commenced?

VW’s response to the claim and the proposed ‘fix’
44. What does VW say about the claim?
45. What is VW’s position on the application for a Group Litigation Order?
46. Why has news of the VW Emissions Issue died down?
47. What is VW doing about this?
48. What is the ‘fix’?
49. Are there any concerns with the ‘fix’?
50. Do I need to have the ‘fix’ carried out?
51. Can I still be a part of the Group Action if I do / do not have the ‘fix’?
52. Hasn’t VW compensated American owners already?
53. Why isn’t VW offering the same to UK owners?

 

 

Background to the claim

1.What is the VW emissions scandal?

On 18 September 2015, the US Environmental Protection Agency ordered Volkswagen to recall 482,000 cars that were found to be producing up to 40 times more emissions than permitted.

On 22 September 2015, Volkswagen admitted that 11 million cars worldwide were fitted with an algorithm built into the car’s engine management software. The software recognised when the car was being tested for emissions, and manipulated engine performance to produce a lower nitrogen oxide (NOx) reading.

We allege that this algorithm was a ‘defeat device’ which meant that – in the real world – affected vehicles were producing more emissions than UK regulations allowed.

The issue is not confined to Volkswagens, and includes all cars manufactured by the Volkswagen Group, namely Volkswagen, Audi, Skoda and SEAT.

Back to top.

 

2. What is the claim about?

The claimants allege that Volkswagen engaged in deceit when it sold vehicles fitted with the ‘defeat device’ and seek compensation.

Back to top.

 

3. What is VW doing about this?

VW’s then Chief Executive has said he was ‘deeply sorry’ for the incident. However, the company has not admitted any wrongdoing. Instead, VW promised to recall and fix any affected vehicle by the end of 2017.

Following proceedings brought in the US, VW has entered into a £14.1 billion settlement to compensate affected owners in the US and to fund clean air projects. By comparison, VW has failed to offer any compensation to owners of affected vehicles elsewhere.

Back to top.

 

4. What is the UK government doing about this?

The Transport Select Committee, made up of MPs from all parties, has criticised the Department for Transport in doing very little to hold VW to account. Similarly, the EU has been unable to fine VW and so is now looking to Member States to bring action and has recently said it plans to take legal action against the UK and Germany for not doing enough.

The Mayor of London, a ‘champion for clean air’, has demanded that VW pay £2.5 million to TFL for lost congestion charge revenue from the 80,000 affected vehicles that been contributing to London’s pollution levels. He has said that he will use the £2.5 million to fund a new schools air quality programme.

Back to top.

 

 

What are the allegations against VW?

5. What legal action (claim) is the VW emissions Action Group going to make? 

The Claimants have alleged that:

  1. the VW Group misled consumers by claiming that the affected vehicles complied with manufacturing and testing regulations;
  2. in fact, the vehicles were fitted with a software algorithm that artificially lowered the level of NOx emissions during environmental testing; and
  3. as a result of this deceit, consumers who purchased an affected vehicle are entitled to compensation for their loss.

It is alleged that the VW Group committed the tort of deceit (which is a type of fraudulent misrepresentation), and breached the Consumer Credit Act 1974 (where financing was provided by VW for the car purchase).

Full details of the claim are set out in the Generic Particulars of Claim, which are available in draft on the registration website.

In joining the action, you will authorise us to sign a Statement of Truth on your behalf in relation to the Generic Particulars of Claim.  

 Back to top.



6. What is it alleged that VW did wrong? 

The Generic Particulars of Claim allege that VW engaged in the following misrepresentations in the sale of the affected vehicles:

  1. that by supplying vehicles with registration numbers and excise licences, VW falsely represented that vehicles complied with the emissions limits set out in the Annex 1 guidelines (the Certificate of Conformity / First Registration Misrepresentation);
  2. that the ‘certificates of conformity’ and registered keepers’ V5 forms quoted false NOx emissions levels (the  NOx Levels Misrepresentation); and
  3. that by permitting the vehicle to be sold, registered, or put into service in the UK, Volkswagen impliedly represented that:
    1. the vehicles complied with all statutory and regulatory requirements imposed by EU and UK law on the vehicles (including the Emissions Regulations, the Testing Regulations and the Annex 1 limits), that all requisite testing had been properly carried out to establish that compliance, and that Type Approval, and all necessary consents, licenses and registration had all been properly obtained without any misrepresentation to the regulators from whom they were obtained;
    2. the vehicles were fit to be lawfully registered, kept and used in the UK or any other member state of the European Union;
    3. the vehicles did not incorporate unlawful ‘Defeat Devices’ preventing the proper and accurate testing of their emissions; and
    4. the vehicles did not require modification in order to meet relevant emissions standards.

(together, the ‘Causing or Permitting the Vehicles to be put into service Misrepresentation’).

 Back to top.


7. What are the rules that govern the sale of motor vehicles? 

The relevant regulations are:

  1. The Construction and Use Regulations 1986 (the 1986 Regulations).
  2. The Road Traffic Act 1988.
  3. The Vehicle Excise and Registration Act 1994.
  4. Directive 2007/46/EC (the Framework Directive).
  5. EC Regulation 715/2007 (the Emissions Regulations).
  6. Commission Regulation EC 692/2008 (the Testing Regulations).
  7. The Road Vehicles (Approval) Regulations 2009 (the 2009 Regulations).

Together these statutes and regulations work like this:

  1. Regulation 6 of the  2009 Regulations provides that ‘first registration’ under the Vehicle Excise and Registration Act will only be granted where an EC Certificate of Conformity (‘COC’) is in effect with respect to the vehicle;
  2. a COC will only have effect if the manufacturer certifies that the vehicle concerned is ‘type approved’;
  3. under the Framework Directive, a vehicle will only be type approved if it complies with the Emissions Regulations;
    1. the Emissions Regulations require compliance with the Testing Regulations;
    2. Article 4(1) of the Emissions Regulations specifies that manufacturers must ‘demonstrate that all new vehicles sold, registered or put into service in the Community are type approved in accordance with this Regulation…These obligations include meeting the emissions limits set out in Annex 1…’; and
    3. Article 5(1) of the Emissions Regulations requires manufacturers to ‘equip vehicles…so as to enable the vehicle, in normal use, to comply with this Regulation…’.
  4. Section 42 of the Road Traffic Act 1988 provides that a vehicle may only be driven lawfully on a UK road if it complies with regulation of 61A of the Construction and Use Regulations 1986. These, in turn, require compliance with the Emissions Regulations.

Accordingly, before it can be sold, registered or driven in the UK, a vehicle must comply with the NOx emissions limits provided in Annex 1 to the Emissions Regulations – not only, in official testing – but also in normal use.

 Back to top.


Joining the group?

8. Why should I claim?

There are many reasons why we believe you should join the claim. The key reasons for doing so, however, are as follows:

  1. It is important that VW be held to account for its actions.  Irrespective of whether the UK Government ultimately decides to take action, it is important that VW owners take a stand and demonstrate that corporate behaviour of this kind will not be tolerated.
  2. We need to do what we can to help the environment. VW marketed diesel vehicles as being the environmentally friendly option, while its cars had been designed to defeat emissions testing regulations. NOx is a pollutant and contributes to dangers such as acid rain, global warming and respiratory conditions. It is each of our responsibility to do what we can to protect our environment.
  3. We believe that you have overpaid for your vehicle, and that its resale value may also be affected. While the amount of individual compensation is likely to be modest, VW should compensate you for the loss you have suffered.  If the case is proven, VW should be made to pay back the extra profits it has made as a result of installing a defeat device instead of creating a legitimate engineering solution to the demands of the Emissions Regulations.

 Back to top.

 

9. What are you asking me to do?

We are asking you to join the group action, by completing the two-stage sign-up process on this website.

Through this process, you will:

  1. appoint the Committee of the VW Emissions Action Group, to represent you in the litigation and to provide instructions on your behalf; and
  2. appoint Harcus Sinclair and Slater and Gordon as your lawyers in the litigation.

Given the number of affected vehicles, it would be impossible for us to take instructions from each and every individual claimant. The appointment of a committee is therefore the mechanism by which we are able to bring proceedings on behalf of everyone that joins the claim. The legal proceedings will aim to bring the VW Group to account for the emissions scandal and to obtain compensation for affected cars owners.

 Back to top.

10. What is the VW Emissions Action Group?

Harcus Sinclair UK Limited is leading the claim against VW and is being supported by Slater and Gordon.  The firms are working together to ensure the best possible outcome for as many affected vehicle owners as possible. The VW Emissions Action Group is therefore a combined force of law firms and their clients seeking to bring VW to account for their actions.

 Back to top.

 

11. What will it cost me?

The litigation will be funded by a third party litigation funder. Accordingly, there will be no cost to you for joining or participating in the group action.

If we lose the claim, the funder will lose all of its investment. To offset its risk, the litigation funder will take a fee from the compensation awarded if we are successful. You should however still receive 70% of your proportionate share of compensation. If we lose the claim, we will not charge you for our time or the costs we have incurred on your behalf.  The funder will simply lose its investment.

 Back to top.

12. How can I be part of the claim?

If you are an owner or have owned an affected vehicle, whether it was purchased new or second hand, you can join the claim by completing the process on this website.

You can instruct us to claim if you have already sold the car.   You can also instruct us to claim if you bought the car outright with cash, or financed it through Volkswagen Financial Services or through any other form of financing.

 Back to top.

13. What do I need to do in order to join the claim?

Joining the claim is straightforward. You need to complete the two-stage sign up process on the website. To be eligible to join the claim, you must have, or have had, an affected vehicle.  If you have never had an affected vehicle then you are not eligible to participate.

You also need to signal your agreement to a number of documents in order for us to act for you. If you do not do so, you cannot join the claim as we will not have the necessary authority to act for you.

 Back to top.

14. What if I want to make a different claim?

We are only bringing those claims that have been set out in the Generic Particulars of Claim.

We acknowledge that you might have additional claims against the VW Group, or have suffered more loss than the average owner. However, we are unable to pursue those individual claims or losses as part of this Group Action.

In order to make this litigation economically viable, it is necessary to concentrate on those aspects that are common to as many individual consumers as possible. If you wish to bring a different claim you will need to seek advice from another solicitor.

 Back to top.

15. Who can bring a claim?

You can join the action if you purchased or owned an affected vehicle, whether it was purchased new or second hand.

You can also participate if you have already sold the affected vehicle, provided that you have proof of your previous ownership (including the vehicle’s VIN number).

You can also instruct us to claim if you bought the car outright with cash, or financed it through Volkswagen Financial Services or through any other form of financing.

 Back to top.

16. How do I know if my car is affected?

You should by now have received a letter confirming your car’s situation by the relevant manufacturer. You can also check to see if your car is affected below:

VW: http://www.volkswagen.co.uk/owners/emissionsinfo  

Audi: https://www.audi.co.uk/owners-area/emissions/check-your-car.html

Seat: http://www.seat.co.uk/owners/diesel-engines/vin-number.html

Skoda: http://www.skoda.co.uk/owners/dieselinfo/check-your-vehicle

Back to top.

 

17. I bought my car in Scotland / Northern Ireland. Can I join the Group Action?

Unfortunately we are unable to act for those people who purchased their cars in Scotland or Northern Ireland. We are investigating how we might help though, and will keep you updated on our progress if you register your interest here.

If you purchased your car in England or Wales and now live in Scotland or Northern Ireland then you can join the action, if you can provide proof of where you purchased the car.

 Back to top.

 

18. Can I still bring a claim if I have sold my affected vehicle?

Yes, so long as you provide evidence of your previous ownership.

 Back to top.


How it works

19. In which Court has the case been brought?

The claims will be brought in the High Court in London due to the complexity and overall value of the claim.

 Back to top.

20. What is a Group Litigation Order? 

A Group Litigation Order (‘GLO’) is a court order that allows a large number of individual cases to be managed together which share common or related issues of fact or law. In a case such as this where the level of compensation per affected vehicle is relatively low, it would not be economically possible to bring claims individually.  A GLO is the accepted way to administer and manage group claims in England and Wales

Harcus Sinclair has applied for a GLO, and the hearing of this application is scheduled to take place on 30th January 2017.   

 Back to top.

21. What is a Group Action?

A Group Action is the nearest UK equivalent to an US class action.

US class actions operate on an ‘opt-out’ basis. That is, a claimant asks the court to certify a class of persons who have a common legal issue to be determined. If the class is certified, then all persons who fall within the class definition are included in the claim unless they opt out.

In a UK Group Action, claimants must ‘opt in’ to the litigation from the outset.  If you do not join the group, then you will not be a claimant and you will not benefit in the event of a successful outcome.

A GLO may be ordered if a number of individuals have claims involving a sufficiently common issue of fact or law, and if the Court believes that the interests of justice are best served by dealing with all of the cases together.

A relatively small number of test cases are chosen, and the court will make findings in respect of those cases that can then be applied to the whole group. This allows a volume of cases to be determined quickly (because the Court does not have to hear each and every case) and dramatically reduces legal costs (because they are shared amongst all of the claimants).     

 Back to top.

22. What documents / information do I need to keep or have to be part of the claim?

It is important that you retain any documents that might be relevant to the case. For example, car brochures, documents relating to your purchase, finance documents and any other documents which were relevant to your decision to purchase the affected vehicle.

If you no longer have those documents then you are still likely to be eligible to participate.

In order to minimise legal costs, we ask that you do not send the documents to us at this stage. We will request them from you when they are required.

 Back to top.

23. What barristers are the VW Emissions Action group using?

We have instructed Oliver Campbell QC, Adam Heppinstall and Nazeer Chowdhury of Henderson Chambers in relation to the claims we are alleging against the VW Group.

http://www.hendersonchambers.co.uk/about-us

In addition we have instructed Gregory Treverton-Jones QC of 39 Essex Chambers to advise this firm on the propriety of the group arrangements we have in place to ensure that we are compliant with our regulatory obligations. Mr Treverton-Jones QC has approved, from a regulatory perspective, all of the documents you will be agreeing to before you are able to join the claim.

http://www.39essex.com/barrister/gregory-treverton-jones-qc/

We have also instructed Alexander Hutton QC of Hailsham Chambers to advise on the funding arrangements in place and to ensure that the claimants’ financial interests are protected.

https://www.hailshamchambers.com/barrister/alexander-hutton-qc/

All members of the Counsel team are very experienced and well-regarded in their field.

 Back to top.

24. Will I have to go to Court if I appoint the VW actions group to represent me?

It is very unlikely that you will need to attend Court.

If a GLO is granted then the Court will likely select a number of test cases that will be representative of the merits and validity of all claims.

These test cases will be seen by the Court as representative of the merits and validity of the claim. The chances of your being a test claimant are clearly slim in light of the size of the claimant group. If, however, you are selected as a test case, you must be prepared to attend Court if requested.  If you are asked to be a witness, we shall guide you through the process.

While this might sound daunting, the process would likely be straightforward. You would be treated respectfully by both the Court and the defendant, and your evidence would likely focus on whether or not you would have purchased the affected vehicle had you known about the defeat device.  

 Back to top.

25. Who are the defendants?

The claim will be against the following companies:

  1. Volkswagen AG (incorporated in Germany);
  2. Audi AG (incorporated in Germany);
  3. Skoda Auto AS (incorporated in Czech Republic);
  4. SEAT SA (incorporated in Spain); and
  5. Volkswagen Financial Services UK Limited (incorporated in England and Wales).

  Back to top.

 

Financial matters

26. How much compensation will I get?

VW owners are encouraged to join this action, not only because of financial motivations, but also to hold VW to account for their deliberate deceit and the damage they have caused to the environment.

We will strive to obtain the maximum recovery on your behalf for the lowest possible cost, and with the least amount of risk.

However, given that VW has not yet offered to ‘fix’ most of the affected vehicles, and because the consequences of the fix are not yet clear, it is not possible to advise definitively about the likely level of compensation. The amount of any damages that are awarded will ultimately be determined by the Court or else negotiated through settlement.

While US claimants received an average $8,000 before costs, damages payments in the UK are likely to be more modest. The US damages payments reflect a number of factors, including stricter regulations, active and aggressive government intervention, and the relative ease of bringing group compensation claims.  Further, we note that the number of affected vehicles is lower, and that VW has admitted that the software constituted a ‘defeat device’ in that jurisdiction.

We expect that UK damages payments will be per vehicle rather than per person and so the more joint owners or previous owners the vehicle has had the lower the damages per owner for that car.

Back to top.

27. What is the loss that is being claimed for? 

We believe that the Court will assess the difference between what you paid for your vehicle and the inherent value of what you actually received. We will argue that the price you paid reflected a range of matters including the vehicle’s reputation for being well-engineered and kind to the environment.  We will argue that you received a vehicle that should never have been licenced for sale because it did not meet the required emissions standards. In addition, we will claim an amount for your inconvenience. If it can be shown that your car has depreciated in value or performance these factors will be relevant to an assessment of loss.

Claimants who bought their vehicles through finance provided by VW Financial Services will have an additional claim.

 Back to top.

 

28. Can we seek to punish VW for its alleged conduct?

In addition to the above, we will make a claim for exemplary damages if we can show that VW deliberately fitted a defeat device to increase its profits.  In the draft Generic Particulars of Claim, we make the following allegation:

Further and/or alternatively, the Claimants seek exemplary damages.  One or more of the Defendants have acted in deliberate and cynical disregard of the Claimants’ rights.  Further, their actions have been motivated by a desire to increase their profits, and were based on a calculation or assumption that the gains to be made from their wrongdoing exceeded the likely fines or compensation payable.  The Claimants are unable to say which of the Defendants are guilty of this conduct prior to disclosure.

The Defendants knew, or must at least have strongly suspected, that the Vehicles contained unlawful defeat devices, that the Vehicles did not meet the Annex 1 limits, and that they did not comply with the Emissions Regulations, the Testing Regulations and the Framework Directive.  The Defendants therefore knew, or must at least have strongly suspected, that the Vehicles emitted greater levels of NOx than was lawfully permitted, and greater levels than had been represented to the Claimants.  Thus the Defendants knew, or must strongly have suspected, that the Vehicles were causing greater damage to human health and the environment than was permitted by UK and European law.   Further, despite that knowledge, the Defendants designed, manufactured and supplied the Vehicles with a Defeat Device instead of investing in and relying upon legitimate research and development, and in doing so were motivated by a desire to increase their profits.

Further, the Defendants cynically sought to hide the existence of the Defeat Device from regulators, from the Secretary of State, and from their customers, including the Claimants.

While we do not know how much VW made as a consequence of the alleged deceit, this should become clear as documents are disclosed in the litigation.

 Back to top.

29. How much of the compensation I am awarded will I get to keep?

This will depend on a number of factors including the overall loss, the number of clients, the amount of time the claim takes, the volume of documents disclosed, and the complexity of the expert evidence.

However, we currently estimate you will keep around 70% of the compensation that is ultimately awarded. The balance will for the costs of solicitors, barristers and experts, as well as the insurance premium, and the litigation funder’s fee.

 Back to top.


30. What is Third Party Funding? 

Third Party Funding is where a third party (not otherwise connected or interested in the claim) agrees to finance all or part of the legal costs of a claim. In return, the Funder receives a fee payable from the proceeds recovered by the Group if the claim is successful. Third Party Funding is therefore a form of alternative investment which although has a high degree of risk, can be well rewarded if a claim is successful. Third Party Funding allows cases to proceed which otherwise would not be able to be run.

 Back to top.

31. Will I get a new car if you win the litigation?

No. If the case is successful, you will receive monetary damages as compensation for any loss you have suffered due to VW’s actions.

 Back to top.

32. How do Harcus Sinclair, Slater and Gordon and the Third Party Funder get paid?

The effect of the funding arrangements is that you will pay nothing unless the case is successful.

If we obtain compensation on your behalf, then you will pay a fee that reflects the financial risk that the Third Party Funders have taken in financing the litigation.

The relationship with the Third Party Funders is governed by the Litigation Funding Agreement which the Committee will execute on your behalf. While the Agreement is commercially sensitive it may be inspected at our offices.

Under the Litigation Funding Agreement, the Third Party Funders will pay any up-front insurance premiums, pay the disbursements associated with the case, pay the fees due to Slater and Gordon under their Conditional Fee Agreement and provide working capital support to make it possible for Harcus Sinclair UK Limited to sustain their DBA.

Provided that the compensation received is enough to give the Third Party Funders more than a return of three times what they have risked, together with the return of their capital, the overall fee that will be taken from your compensation is 30%. The cost of distributing the settlement fund will be in addition to that fee.

This arrangement is reflective of the risk being taken by the Third Party Funders in agreeing to fund the claim.

 Back to top.

 

33. Do I still need to be making my monthly payments to VW Financial Services if I am suing VW?

Yes. We would strongly urge you to continue to make your contractual payments. The fact that you are engaged in litigation with VW does not mean you are able to breach your current contractual obligations to VW and may result in any award of damages being reduced accordingly.

 Back to top.

 

Environmental issues

34. What is NOx?

NOx is a pollutant. It is the generic term for the oxides of nitrogen: NO, N2O and NO2. NOx is the result of the nitrogen in the air reacting with the oxygen in the air during combustion that is needed for the oxidisation of the fuel to produce energy. NOx is also harmful to humans and the environment which is why its emissions are controlled and regulated.  

Back to top.

35. What effect does NOx have on the environment? 

NOx is a pollutant which has a negative impact on the environment in a number of forms. Some examples are as follows:

  • An increase in ground-level ozone (also referred to as smog): This forms Ozone, or smog, which damages vegetation and crop yields, as well as health implications.

 

  • An increase in acid rain: acid rain is responsible for damaging forests, causing lakes and streams to become acidic and poisoning wildlife in addition to damaging buildings, monuments and cars.

 

  • A deterioration of water quality: Affecting the levels of nutrients available to plants and animals; causes a form of water pollution, whereby algae growth is accelerated, depleting the oxygen available and reducing aquatic life.

 

  • Contributes to Global Warming: Slowly causing the earth’s temperature to rise, contributions to global warming will affect sea level, destroying plants and animal habitats.

 

DEFRA believe that more than 23,000 people in the UK die prematurely every year because of NOx.

 Back to top.

 

36. What effect does NOx have on our health? 

In the US, the Environmental Protection Agency has asserted that breathing air with a high concentration of NO2 can irritate airways and cause respiratory issues (coughing, wheezing or difficulty breathing). It has also reported that high levels of exposure to NO2 may aggravate respiratory conditions such as asthma and increase susceptibility to respiratory infections.

In the UK, the Department for Environment Food and Rural Affairs has claimed that exposure to ‘particulate matter’ from emissions has been estimated to reduce average life expectancy in the UK by six months. Defra estimates that the UK death rate is 4% higher due to NOx pollution, causing 23,500 extra deaths per year.

The level of NOx pollutants is estimated to cost UK public health services over £16 billion per year.

 Back to top.

 

What being in the claim will mean for me

37. Can I speak to a lawyer about the progress of the claim?

In order for this claim to be financially viable, it is essential we keep costs to a minimum. As the case progresses, we will keep the group updated by way of email updates.  We will also update the content and FAQs on our website. If there is something you are not clear about and require a specific response to, you can submit a web query which will be answered within 48 hours.

 Back to top.

38. How long will the litigation take?

We expect VW strongly to defend the claim. It is difficult to estimate the likely timeframe but it is anticipated that the litigation could take between 18 – 24 months to get to trial.

 Back to top.

39. How will I know what the outcome is and what happens next? 

As the case progresses, we will keep the group updated by way of email updates.  We will also update the content and FAQs on our website. If, however, there is something you are not clear about and require a specific response to, you can submit a web query.  Rather than respond individually, we propose regularly to update the FAQs and to send them to the group as updates.

 Back to top.

40. What are my risks?

Any claimants involved in a Court case could be ordered to pay the defendants’ legal costs if they lose. This is a characteristic of the Court system in England and Wales. In order to protect claimants from that risk, we have obtained an indemnity from the Third Party Funder who are responsible for obtaining insurance.  If the case is lost, it will be the Third Party Funder or their insurers who will pay the other side’s costs up to the level of the amount insured. It is our duty to minimise the risk to you as far as possible, and the funder’s indemnity and Insurance should mean that the risk will be negligible. Other risks are referred to in the Claim Summary document, which we have prepared and which is available to prospective claimants during the registration process.

 Back to top.

 

41. How can I sign up for updates? 

There is a link to sign up to updates on the homepage of the registration website.

 Back to top.

42. What if I have already signed up with another group?

If you have only expressed an interest to join another group and there is no retainer in place, you are free to instruct whomsoever you please. If you have expressed an interest to join either Harcus Sinclair or Slater and Gordon’s group, you should complete the necessary sign up process on the registration website as it represents a claim being brought on behalf of both firms. If you have been formally retained as a client by another firm for this action, we unfortunately cannot accept your instructions. If you are unsure as to whether you have been formally retained by another firm, we recommend that you contact that firm to ascertain the position.

 Back to top.

43. What happens if I want to leave the Group Action once it has commenced?

We suggest that you do not join unless you are willing to see the claim through to completion. We have designed the claim so that your risks are minimised. However if you do chose to leave the Group Action once it has commenced then you will be liable to pay a portion of our costs in proportion to the number of vehicles you are claiming for. For example if there are 20,000 vehicles, and you are claiming for one, then your liability for our costs will be 1/20,000th. You will also be responsible to cover VW’s costs to that point in the same proportion. Therefore leaving the Group Action is not advised as it will only mean incurring costs which may be avoided if you remain until the conclusion of the claim.

 Back to top.

 

VW’s response to the claim and the proposed ‘fix’

44. What does VW say about the claim?

When the scandal broke in September 2015, VW’s then Chief Executive said that he was ‘deeply sorry’ for the incident. They have since committed to recall and fix all affected vehicles by the end of 2017 but have offered no compensation to affected owners. We have seen documentation whereby VW admit that the affected vehicles did not comply with the necessary regulations. In public VW has denied that this is the case. We do not yet know how VW will defend the claim but we shall keep the claimant group updated as the case progresses.

 Back to top.

45. What is VW’s position on the application for a Group Litigation Order?

VW has confirmed in correspondence that they in principal agree that if a large number of claims are issued and pursued against VW, it may be necessary for such claims to be managed by way of a GLO. As the claimant group is already large and is continuing to grow, we believe it is in VW’s best interest for a GLO to be made as it will allow them to more effectively manage the case put against them.

 Back to top.

46. Why has news of the VW Emissions Issue died down?

VW has done a very good job of repeatedly saying that it does not matter, as they have committed to fixing all of the affected vehicles at no cost to the owner. Our case is that this is not the point: customers have been misled, huge damage has been done to the environment in the meantime and there is no evidence to suggest that the fix is effective without negative repercussions to the affected vehicles. We strongly suspect that VW want to delay the hearing of this case until those people who bought their cars new have sold them. We also suspect that by delaying matters VW hope that the emissions scandal will be seen as old news and one which people have lost interest in.  We do not believe this is acceptable and believe that VW should be held to account for their actions.

It is also particularly noteworthy that VW’s approach to the scandal has been inconsistent. We believe this is illustrative of a lack of transparency and accountability to their customers and again something they should be held to account for. By way of example, VW notified the Driver & Vehicle Standards Agency on the 1 October 2015 that the nitrogen emissions levels in the affected vehicles did not meet Euro 5 regulatory requirements. They have now, however, stated that ‘with the benefit of legal analysis’ this is no longer the case. A link to this document can be found here.

We are also sceptical as to the purpose of the recent advertising campaigns VW has been running that stress concepts such as ‘trust’. It is difficult to accept such campaigns as genuine in light of their recent behaviour. Again, we believe that before customers can be asked to ‘trust’ the brand again, VW should be held to account for their actions and their customers compensated for their behaviour.

 Back to top.

47. What is VW doing about this?

VW are now carrying out a ‘fix’ to the 1.2 million affected cars. VW have not told us exactly what this fix consists of but the aim of it is to make sure the cars comply with the emissions levels when not in the test cycle (i.e. when being driven normally). 1.2 litre and 2.0 litre engines will need a software fix, but 1.6 litre engines will also need a mechanical fix. The fixes were due to be completed by the end of 2016; however, to date VW have fixed a little over 10% of the cars and so we expect the fixes to continue well into 2017 and beyond.

 Back to top.

48. What is the ‘fix’?

One of the key complaints is that nobody knows what the ‘fix’ entails. VW will not tell their customers what it involves. Shockingly, we have had reports of ‘fixes’ being carried out by VW garages unbeknownst to customers simply taking their affected vehicle in for a service.

 Back to top.

49. Are there any concerns with the ‘fix’?

Due to the lack of information VW have been willing to provide, it is difficult to ascertain what the result of the fix may be. We have spoken to experts in vehicle emissions and testing and suspect that, to some extent, VW will be able to 'remap' the vehicles' ECUs (electricity control units) so that published fuel economy and performance figures do not change noticeably. This doesn't tell the full story though, and we believe it is likely that in real world (not artificial, prescribed fuel economy tests, for example) driving, the performance of affected vehicles will, to some extent, be damaged.

There are anecdotal reports of vehicles becoming thirstier and slower (see the honest John Website, for example), and we have commissioned independent tests to try and reach a conclusion on this issue.

 Back to top.

50. Do I need to have the ‘fix’ carried out?

No. There is no legal obligation for you to have the ‘fix’ if you do not want to. VW have said the affected vehicles remain roadworthy in their current state and that they will not fail their MOT because of the NOx issue.

As we do not know precisely how the fix works, we cannot definitively say whether owners of affected vehicles ought to have their cars fixed or not. At this stage we do not think that having your car fixed will compromise your claim.  The reason behind this is that, regardless of the effect of the fix, you will still (we believe) have overpaid for vehicle at the point of purchase and should be compensated accordingly.

 Back to top.

51. Can I still be a part of the Group Action if I do / do not have the ‘fix’?

You can be part of the Group Action against VW regardless of whether you have had or not had your affected vehicle ‘fixed’. You will still have overpaid for your vehicle at the point of purchase and have been should be compensated accordingly.

 Back to top.

52. Hasn’t VW compensated American owners already?

Yes. VW has come to a $15bn settlement with VW owners in the USA. This was arrived at following several class actions and considerable political and regulatory pressure.  

 Back to top.

53. Why isn’t VW offering the same to UK owners?

VW say the situation in the UK is very different to the USA in that they can fix the cars in the UK whereas they can’t in the USA. VW are not inclined to make any offers of goodwill to UK owners nor are they offering to buy back affected vehicles. Our view is that this is mis-guided and VW’s approach has more to do with appeasing aggressive US regulators and warding off potential criminal prosecutions.

 Back to top.

 
personal.png

Personal

For individuals who would like to join the legal case 

JOIN THE CLAIM
business.png

Business Owners

For companies or commercial organisations 

JOIN THE CLAIM
Subscribe to receive news updates